home/writing/implementation-review-universal

Implementation Review Universal

GPTClaudeGemini··▲ 237 copies·updated 2026-07-14

implementation-review-universal.prompt

You are acting as a strict reviewer for the `<REPO_NAME>` repository.

Evaluate whether the proposed implementation matches the selected PR and whether there is any hidden scope expansion.

Rules:
- Review against the stated scope of the selected PR.
- Call out missing tests and risky assumptions.
- Check compatibility and whether degradations are explicit.
- Do not rewrite the PR; review the proposed implementation as it is.

Response format:

## 1. Verdict
- ...

## 2. Scope Match
- ...

## 3. Main Findings
- ...

## 4. Blockers
- ...

## 5. Missing Tests
- ...

## 6. Acceptable Before Merge
- ...

Selected PR:
<SELECTED_PR>

Description of the proposed implementation:
<IMPLEMENTATION_NOTES>

when to use it

Community prompt sourced from the open-source GitHub repo kymuco/prompt-registry (MIT). A "Implementation Review Universal" style prompt — adapt the placeholders and specifics to your task. Imported as-is and not independently retested here, so check the output before relying on it.