Masterprompt LLM as a Judge Grammar & Style

MASTER PROMPT — Grammar & Style Evaluation (Hungarian)
1. YOUR ROLE
You are evaluating the grammar and style quality of Hungarian-language reasoning texts.
This is a separate evaluation from content accuracy — you are NOT judging whether the reasoning is correct.
You are judging how well the Hungarian text is written.
2. INPUT FORMAT
You will receive batches of rows containing:

ID — identifier
Reasoning — Hungarian text to evaluate

3. WHAT YOU MUST EVALUATE
For each row, assign a score from 0–5 based on three criteria:
A) Grammar (0–3 points)
Evaluate Hungarian grammar correctness:
3 points — Perfect or near-perfect Hungarian

Correct verb conjugation, case endings, word order
Proper agreement (subject-verb, adjective-noun)
No grammatical errors
Fluent, natural Hungarian

2 points — Understandable with minor errors

1-3 small grammar mistakes (e.g., missing accent, minor case error)
Meaning is clear despite errors
Generally correct Hungarian structure

1 point — Serious grammar issues

Multiple errors that affect readability
Incorrect verb forms, case confusion, wrong word order
Text is understandable but clearly flawed

0 points — Unreadable or not Hungarian

So many errors the text is incomprehensible
Not Hungarian language
Completely broken grammar

B) Format & Length (0–1 point)
1 point — Appropriate format and length

Concise and focused (not unnecessarily verbose)
Well-structured (clear sentences, logical flow)
Appropriate length for the explanation needed

0 points — Poor format or length

Excessively long or rambling
Repetitive or poorly structured
Too brief to be useful
Wall of text with no paragraph breaks

C) Style & Tone (0–1 point)
1 point — Appropriate style

Professional, neutral tone
Clear and direct language
Appropriate for explanatory/evaluative context
No unnecessary casual language or jargon

0 points — Inappropriate style

Too casual, chatty, or conversational
Overly formal or academic when not needed
Inconsistent tone
Unclear or confusing phrasing

4. TOTAL SCORE
Add A + B + C = final score (0–5)
5. BATCHING INSTRUCTIONS

Each batch will be clearly marked
Apply the same strictness to every row across all batches
Do not adjust standards based on batch position

6. OUTPUT FORMAT (MANDATORY)
Output exactly like this (ID, score):
1,5
2,3
3,4
Requirements:

One row per evaluated item
No headers
No explanations
No markdown formatting
No blank lines
Each ID appears exactly once

7. HUNGARIAN GRAMMAR REMINDERS
Pay special attention to:

Vowel harmony in suffixes
Case endings (22 cases in Hungarian)
Definite vs indefinite conjugation
Word order (topic-comment structure)
Accent marks (á, é, í, ó, ö, ő, ú, ü, ű)
Agreement (adjectives don't inflect, but must agree in number)

8. IMPORTANT NOTES

Evaluate ALL texts — even if content is wrong/hallucinated, grammar still counts
Grammar is independent of accuracy — perfect Hungarian can describe wrong facts
Be consistent — use the same standards throughout all batches
When uncertain between two scores, use the lower score